Case Evidence · CE-168
Emenegger/Shartle Holloman landing-film narrative; timing and interpretation disputed; do not assume identical to alleged 1964 event.
AllegedEarly 1970s / later recollections · Retrospective documentary-production accounts
Record
- Date / period
- Early 1970s / later recollections
- Reported event / document
- Emenegger/Shartle Holloman landing-film narrative; timing and interpretation disputed; do not assume identical to alleged 1964 event.
- Evidence type
- Retrospective documentary-production accounts
- Original data accessible?
- No authenticated original landing film established
- Verification status
- Narrative historically reported; alleged footage/contact unverified
- Competing explanations / missing data
- Conflicting chronology and interpretations including conventional explanations
- Next step
- Trace interviews, original production correspondence and Air Force film catalogues. Chunk M search (2026-11-12): The 1974 film UFOs: Past, Present and Future used drawings in place of the promised footage; no Air Force film catalogue entry, production correspondence or Shartle statement on record was found online. Flag stays.
- Source ID
- SRC-163
Why this grade
Alleged From Case Evidence's Verification status ("Narrative historically reported; alleged footage/contact unverified"). Grade rules.