Case Evidence · CE-V99-117
Elizondo's Socorro narrative: other motorists, explosion-like sound, separate white butane-tank-shaped object, comparison with 2004 Nimitz Tic Tac
Unverified2024 (publication) · Attributed narrative (memoir)
Record
- Date / period
- 2024 (publication)
- Reported event / document
- Elizondo's Socorro narrative: other motorists, explosion-like sound, separate white butane-tank-shaped object, comparison with 2004 Nimitz Tic Tac
- Evidence type
- Attributed narrative (memoir)
- Original data accessible?
- No
- Verification status
- Uncorroborated witness leads; analogy only
- Competing explanations / missing data
- Other witnesses unnamed; propulsion descriptions differ from Nimitz
- Next step
- Find named firsthand statements; keep comparison separate from identity claims. Chunk M search (2026-11-12): The 1964 Blue Book case file (SRC-V99-091) records the leads Elizondo names: p. 16, a KGRT news script (28 Apr 1964) on Orlando Gallegos's 'egg shaped butane tank' object, but at La Madera, not Socorro; p. 72, a Telegraph-Herald letter to Hynek naming Paul Kies and Larry Kratzer of Dubuque as witnesses; pp. 111 and 138, Hynek on the unidentified tourist who told Opal Grinder (Whiting Bros. station, US 85) the object flew over his car. Zamora's statement in the FBI file (SRC-V99-090 pp. 9-10): 'Noise was a roar, not a blast', and he first thought the dynamite shack had blown up. All second-hand except Zamora's; the Tic Tac comparison remains Elizondo's analogy.
- Source ID
- SRC-233; SRC-V99-091; SRC-V99-090
Why this grade
Unverified From Case Evidence's Verification status ("Uncorroborated witness leads; analogy only"). Grade rules.