Evidence Log · E-V99-040
Dr. Wellaide Cecim Carvalho told Bob Pratt and Daniel Rebisso Giese in 1993 she treated about 40 people with burns and that two died
Claim unverifiedFirsthand1977; interviewed 1993 · Reported direct interview by researcher
Record
- Date
- 1977; interviewed 1993
- Claim or item
- Dr. Wellaide Cecim Carvalho told Bob Pratt and Daniel Rebisso Giese in 1993 she treated about 40 people with burns and that two died
- Evidence category
- Reported direct interview by researcher
- Firsthand?
- Carvalho firsthand as treating physician; relayed by interviewer
- Publicly accessible?
- Yes (Pratt compilation)
- Independent corroboration
- No clinical charts, causes of death or patient identities provided
- Assessment
- Reported clinical recollection; causation unestablished
- Notes
- SRC-V99-050 p. 7. Chunk M search (2026-11-12): No file on this site mentions Colares, Carvalho, Uchoa or Pratt's tallies. Carvalho's only other published statement found is a 2005 interview in Revista UFO (Carlos Mendes; English reprint at ufology.patrickgross.org/htm/colareswc.htm): it describes light-beam symptoms and says the military made her understate them, but gives no burn or death count. No medical records found online. The one I COMAR register read in chunk G (archive item ARX 184: 130 forms, Sep 1977 to Nov 1978) records no deaths and few injuries, which cuts against the death counts. Uchoa's dinner remark has no record outside Imminent. Flag stays.
- Linked case IDs
- CASE-035
Why this grade
Claim unverifiedFirsthand From the Evidence Log's Assessment ("Reported clinical recollection; causation unestablished"), and Firsthand? ("Carvalho firsthand as treating physician; relayed by interviewer"). Grade rules.